It was time. The trusty, green, plastic compost bucket that lived under my sink for many years had to go. For months, I dealt with the cracked top rim but when the handle snapped off completely (showering my legs with compost - thankfully outside!), I knew that its days were numbered. Even though my plastic bucket held up for many years, I wasn't so sure I wanted another one of the same model. So I took to the internet to do some research on what type of compost container to buy:
Factors to Consider
Assuming that you have a place to compost food scraps outside, you will need some type of container to store them temporarily in the house. Here are a few questions to ask yourself:
- Will the container be kept under the sink or on the counter? If it's sitting out on the counter you will probably want something that looks nice. If not, butt ugly might be just fine.
- What material is the container made of? Popular choices are stainless steel, plastic and ceramic.
- How much does the container hold? If you create a lot of food scraps, you will want to lean towards something larger. If not, a smaller size will suit you just fine. Most containers hold between 1 gallon and 2.5 gallons.
- What type of filter does it use? Most compost buckets use a charcoal filter but the key question is - are they readily available? If not, you might want to consider a different model.
Read the Reviews
I was all set to buy an inexpensive, stainless steel compost bucket, when I read that rusting was a problem and replacement filters were hard to find. Goes to show you, there's more to a purchase than reading the product description! Here's the type of thing I found in the customer feedback section:
- Problems with rusting on stainless models
- Lids didn't fit well or filter fell out easily
- Fruit fly and/or odor problem
- Hard to find replacement filters
- Not big enough for customer needs
My Choice
In the end, I chose the SimpleHuman Stainless Compost Pail. Stainless steel seemed like the best option for many reasons - more durable, more eco-friendly and better looking. And even though I store my container under the sink, I use it a ton so I wanted something that looked nice sitting on my counter while I am using it. This model was more expensive than many of the other choices, but it got great reviews and met most of the criteria that were important to me. Plus it has a 5 year warranty!! The one downside is that it is smaller than my old plastic bin (it holds 1.2 gallons vs. 2.4 for the old one). So far that hasn't bothered me very much although come CSA season, it might.
Do you keep a compost bucket in your kitchen? What do you like best about it?
(Disclosure: There are affiliate links in this post. Any purchase you make helps keep this blog in business. Thank you!)
This is a very timely post. Thank you. The bucket I just ended up purchasing looks very much like yours. Now I'm concerned about rust-didn't think of that. I'm also worried that it will be too small. Does the Simple Human have a filter?
Posted by: Lori Popkewitz Alper | February 27, 2013 at 12:18 PM
Lori - yes the simplehuman bucket has came with 2 filters and you can buy more on Amazon. I hope yours works out for you!
Posted by: Micaela | February 27, 2013 at 03:43 PM
Lori - yes the simplehuman bucket has came with 2 filters and you can buy more on Amazon. I hope yours works out for you!
Posted by: Micaela | February 27, 2013 at 03:43 PM
Lori - yes the simplehuman bucket has came with 2 filters and you can buy more on Amazon. I hope yours works out for you!
Posted by: Micaela | February 27, 2013 at 03:43 PM
Lori - yes the simplehuman bucket has came with 2 filters and you can buy more on Amazon. I hope yours works out for you!
Posted by: Micaela | February 27, 2013 at 03:43 PM
I do compost, and I can honestly say that I do not have a store-bought compost bucket. I use 1-gallon milk jugs that I cut the top off of, and I keep them under the sink. I've never noticed a need for a filter, and I often have compost sitting under there for several days before I get around to emptying it. It gets gross - I usually soak it in water and soap for a few hours right after I empty it, but I don't really scrub it, just rinse it. When it gets too gross to be cleaned that way, I get rid of it, and start again. This works for me now because my kids drink a lot of milk so I always have gallon milk jugs to repurpose. When they stop doing that, I'll have to come up with something else.
Posted by: Stacey | February 27, 2013 at 09:34 PM
We keep our compost bucket on the countertop, so I chose a nice looking stainless steel one too. So far, so good!
Posted by: Kiersten @ Oh My Veggies | February 28, 2013 at 07:27 AM
I had a ceramic one for years that worked very well. It has a carbon filter and I never noticed an odor problem. I am in the market for a new one though. I left this one outside, in the cold and now it has a huge crack! I'll have to look into the SimpleHuman one. Although I might need something larger.
Posted by: Kristina (The Greening Of Westford) | February 28, 2013 at 09:18 AM
Good luck finding the right compost bucket Kristina! I thought the ceramic ones looked nice but I was a little worried about durability.
Posted by: Micaela | February 28, 2013 at 12:17 PM
Kiersten - how often do you have to dump yours? You must have a lot of food scraps with all the cooking you do!
Posted by: Micaela | February 28, 2013 at 12:18 PM
Glad to hear that the gallon jugs work for you Stacey. Way to repurpose!!
Posted by: Micaela | February 28, 2013 at 12:20 PM
We have a compost outside but I really like the idea of having one like this inside! Really good post.
Posted by: Alicia@ eco friendly homemaking | March 03, 2013 at 07:12 PM
We compost and recycle at the office, infact we have chickens there too now and throw out lunch leftovers to them! However...warning it does encourage rats as we have found out! About me...I run the Green Careers Site at www.Stopdodo.com (as in the extinct bird... also online at www.environmentjobs.com!). I would be interested in writing free content in your blog area regarding career prospects, trends, hot areas, tip etc. Our site centres on environmental jobs / green jobs in the sectors climate change, nature, ecology, recycling, lowcarbon etc.
Love this site by the way!
Posted by: Andy | March 06, 2013 at 03:15 AM
I have that green bucket. :)
Posted by: Tiffany (NatureMom) | March 06, 2013 at 11:16 AM
Very nice post and so helpful. Getting the right equipment for composting is important so that we can have the positive aspects of it without the downsides (smell, flies,...). http://yourgreencity.com
Posted by: Martha | March 07, 2013 at 01:04 AM
Has the green bucket held up for you Tiffany? Mine did for a few years actually but when the handle broke, it was done for. :)
Posted by: Micaela | March 07, 2013 at 07:55 AM
Yep, you definitely don't want the smell and the fruit flies. Thanks for stopping by Martha!
Posted by: Micaela | March 07, 2013 at 07:58 AM